Skip to main content

Does Harness Racing Need a New Triple Crown?

In literally hundreds of racing articles, both standardbred and thoroughbred, we’ve heard that racing is one of the few sports that don’t have a season. There seems to be no beginning or end, and those who say that seem to have a strong point.

However, I was doing some office work a few weeks ago and took a look at some internet traffic stats on the bellwether Daily Racing Form website (, via Quantcast.

What we notice is a large spike in traffic and interest starting in late April, and it lasts to about late June. This coincides almost perfectly with Triple Crown. If we go back and look at years past, it’s exactly the same.  There is a season in thoroughbred racing; the fans are telling you when it begins and ends. 

If we pull up the same graphs for harness racing, whether it is website statistics, search terms, or news mentions, we do not see such a spike throughout our calendar.  Even storied races like the Little Brown Jug, Hambletonian, or other big money events like the North America Cup barely seem to register in any tangible way.

It can be argued the Triple Crown series in thoroughbred racing keeps that sport on the nation’s radar, and has for many years. Handles for the three races (and race cards) can make a track’s entire year, and it’s one of the few times that the television networks pay racing to show the races, not the other way around. 

Is harness racing missing out?

I asked some fans on Twitter if they could name the three races that comprise the Pacing Triple Crown, and only a couple of them even knew what I was talking about.  I’ve followed the sport since I was 11 years old, and I can’t honestly tell you with 100 percent accuracy where the Cane Pace will be held this year, or when exactly the Messenger will be scheduled.

“The Pacing Triple Crown is obsolete and has been for decades,” said Perretti Farms’ Bob Marks. “No one can decide what to do, if anything, and they’ve talked about it.”

In the 21st century in racing, I believe we don’t really need board meetings and votes to decide what races should be in or out of a Triple Crown, we should simply let the market decide.

The market says the $1.5 million Pepsi North America Cup should be the first leg of the Triple Crown. Not only has the race been endorsed by horsemen and horse owners as the first big tilt for sophomores, it has been endorsed by fans. Over $3 million is bet annually on the card, and Woodbine Entertainment Group promotes it well. On-track attendance, since moving the event from cavernous Woodbine Racetrack to cozy Mohawk Racetrack, has swelled. Last year, just like the previous few years, I had to dodge fans on the tarmac, ensuring I didn’t spill any of my drink, which we all know is rare for our harness events.  Canada’s Score Television Network, which is available in millions of homes, televises it each year, too.

The Preakness Stakes tends to keep the buzz going for the thoroughbred Triple Crown because it is held only two weeks after the Derby. The $1 million Meadowlands Pace fits that to a “t,” and it should be our second leg.  Jeff Gural has been trying to grow the Meadowlands and perhaps the public, the media and government will take us more seriously if the Meadowlands Pace is more than a stand-alone event.  It has a big purse, it has cache, and it has a good history. In addition, punters love the Meadowlands, and earlier this decade it was not uncommon to see over $5 million bet on this race card. This is an easy choice for leg two, even if the purse has to come down over the next few years.

My final leg will be the Little Brown Jug. If you ask people outside racing to name a harness race, chances are this race will be mentioned.  The event plays well on television with heats and a final, and the huge crowd is a massive bonus for us. This enables us to leverage crowdsource and buzz; two items vital for a strong event nowadays. It’s on a half-mile track as well, which adds to the flavor. It is a unique event.

There are pluses and minuses in choosing the above three races, but when we group them together, I believe they work.

Marketer and 21st century marketing consultant Seth Godin in All Marketers are Liars researches the reasons we buy a $200 pair of sneakers that feel similar to a $50 pair, or pay $3.50 for a coffee when we can drink the same brand from a coffee pod at work for 40 cents.

Godin wrote, “Successful marketers don’t talk about features or even benefits. Instead they tell a story. A story we want to believe.”

The three races that make up our new Pacing Triple Crown tell a wonderful story; one that fits the image of harness racing and harness horses like a glove.

“Three races, three size tracks, culminating in a final leg where an iron tough harness horse struts his stuff in front of 40,000 fans in Ohio, having to win two races on the same day to be crowned champion.”

Try and top that story.

It’s been a long time since racing was a monopoly. In the old days a gym bag giveaway at Greenwood Raceway in downtown Toronto would ensure an overflow crowd. In 2012, it’s not that way at all. We need events and a story.  A new Pacing Triple Crown might help us usher in a new era, give us something to promote to the masses, and bring more fans to our wonderful sport. It’s a story that I think needs to be written.

 This article originally appeared in Harness Racing Update. To subscribe for free, please click here.


Anonymous said…
The three races are all good choices, but there's too much time between the Meadowlands Pace and the Jug to keep people interested in a Triple Crown.

The third leg needs to be no later than early August. The question, what race would fit? Only the Adios in PA comes to mind.

The sad part of this discussion is the questionable future of Canadian racing puts the N. A. Cup in doubt and The Meadowlands is still iffy. Only Delaware, Ohio appears to be a sure thing for now. Think Ohio could move the fair dates?
Pacingguy said…
I can't argue with your choices. Of course, that assumes there will be a Pepsi North America Cup to include:-(
Alpha Link said…
Not bad at all... (for a consultant or whatever!)
IMO the Jug has to be the anchor - purses be damned. This game is flailing around looking for a draw for the public (we'll forget about rake for the moment) It's imperative that we build on tradition, the heart-stirring calls from Jugs past etc. If we boil it all down to it's filthiest essence, Pepsi Cups, etc. we're pandering to sponsors that couldn't give a rat's ass whether the sport lives or dies. this whole sponsorship thing stinks - if the sport can't survive without it, then die with dignity.
No argument to the three different track configurations, but it should culminate in a battle of guts over a half in heats... that will weed out the shrinking violets.
Cheers, AL

Popular posts from this blog

Sword Dancer Shenanigans Proves the Public's Point

Ask any random person who has not watched a horse race, or maybe have seen one or three : "Is horse racing fixed?"

They'll probably say, sure it is; common knowledge.

At that point, racing folks get excited to defend their sport. 99% of the races are clean, there is too much money involved to fix races, etc etc. 

Then we have yesterday's Sword Dancer, where not one of us can blame anyone for thinking like they do about the sport.

It's probably bad enough that a "rabbit" was entered for an old-time form of race fixing, but that the horse was ridden like a quarterhorse made the optics look terrible. That another horse - Roman Approval - had to be physically restrained due to the cowboy style race riding of the horse sent to destroy him, is probably just as bad optically.

But that was just the beginning. The real story had just begun.

At the head of the lane, this rank, spent, heart-ripped out rabbit, needed to do even more work for the 1-9 shot. He had t…

If #harnessracing is Afraid of the Answer......

There's a saying, apparently, from the legal community - never ask a question if you don't know the answer.

Today at the USTA meeting Jason Settlemoir put forth a motion that the USTA ask its membership the feelings on a question regarding slots and marketing. In a nutshell, it asked if a percentage of slot money should go into a slush fund to be spent on marketing and ancillary items to promote and grow the sport.

When the 54 director votes were tallied, the score was 47 to 7..... against.

Yes, the leadership of an organization voted down, in a landslide, asking the grassroots membership a question. 

Sure this seems super-silly, but why they did it, I think, is an easy one. They knew that if they asked the question the answer would be a resounding "yes". Then all hell would break loose. They'd have to try and get that done.

If harness racing is afraid of the answers to questions, they don't ask them. That seems to be the mantra of the sport. And it's p…

PTP's Bathing Index ® Derby Handicapping Angles - This is Much Better than Dosage

Good day racing fans!

It's one week until the Derby, where drunk people, rich people, sororities at almost every University, and others get together to watch, wager, take molly, drink juleps, wear hats, have parking issues, and partake in the annual Kentucky horse racing tradition.

I have scanned the big websites, read almost all social media and was very surprised that there are not a lot of people giving their thoughts on this year's Run for the Roses. It's like no one has an opinion! So in my never ending search for traffic, I decided to pop up a handicapping post. I think this post will help both new fans and old salty handicappers land on a winner.

As most know, physicality is important for handicapping (Leadbetter, et al). A lesser known angle is watching how a horse reacts while getting soapy water thrown on him. As long time handicapper Jessica notes, it can be a key to unlocking Derby betting fortune.


Let's begin with our control group, Kentucky Derby …