Crunk and Bill Finley have been having a chat on twitter with respect to Bill's "rant" on late odds drops.
In some corners of horse racing late odds drops are a function of the prevaailing us versus them narrative - the one in which "computer players" are hammering the pools late, and they're only to blame for it happening. Again, in some quarters, the solution to this is simple - ban them.
Leaving aside the fact that horse racing is not in any position (most businesses aren't, of course) to tell bettors not to give them money, it's a reaction that, in my view, lacks nuance.
As Crunk duly notes, most of the money comes in late now - your money, my money, the "computer guy's" money. With so little bet early, it's inevitable late odds changes will happen. It is not an exchange or fixed odds, it's pari-mutuel.
If you banned "computer guy" you'd still have late odds changes. Maybe it won't be quite as much, or quite as noticeable, because they are clearly a large force in the changes, but it will still be there. A 4-1 horse who is 7-1 at one minute to post is still a 4-1 horse. It's just the way gambling works.
Down the horse racing grapevine, which may or may not be accurate, I heard the teams often switch tactics and instead of betting most of their cash late, they trickle in money at various points of the wagering. Has anyone noticed a difference in late odds changes, if that's true? I sure haven't.
Horse racing twitter - any twitter, really - is not a place to discuss nuance. It's about being on one side (big huge bettors!) versus the other side (the rest of us), and the labels it all brings. In many cases - like this one - the sides don't matter, because the tribes are irrelevant.
Odds drops happen because the system lends itself for them to happen. And the system is not going to change any time soon. As silly as it all is, and how maddening it can be, bettors and customers need to learn that a 6-1 horse who's paying 3-1 in the doubles is going down to 3-1.
Have a great Monday everyone.
Monday, July 15, 2019
Monday, July 8, 2019
Inevitable Change is Inevitable
The Calgary Stampede is under way for yet another year, and looking at the record attendance numbers from day one - over the two weeks it attracts upwards of 1.5 million fans - it should be a well-attended event.
The Stampede, over the years, but especially in 2012 when 9 horses perished, has been the target of animal activists. In response, some changes were made.
Since that time:
The Stampede, over the years, but especially in 2012 when 9 horses perished, has been the target of animal activists. In response, some changes were made.
Since that time:
- Animal researchers have been given full access to all animals and data, and are allowed to publish, and make recommendations.
- The Calgary Humane Society and SPCA are given unfettered access to the grounds.
- Vet checks before and after competitions, days of rest, and other procedures for safety were put in place.
- All animals are chipped and the chip keeps track of all vet work and drug treatments; and are logged and stored, and made public.
- Rules have been changed - in fact, the sport of calf roping is completely changed now, and if the contestant competes the 'old way', they are disqualified.
- The Board of the event is comprised of people from the community, including SPCA volunteers.
The above, naturally, has not satisfied the activists - nothing but a ban would. However, the general public has been on board, and most-importantly, so have the politicians who hold power over the event. The prevailing thought this year is that, no, the event in Calgary is not in jeopardy.
Horse racing has reached a similar crossroads, and if we truly examine it, some good things have been done.
But, the changes are nowhere near as comprehensive, quick, thoughtful and effective as the Stampede.
In horse racing a simple whip change causes consternation that can last three social media lifetimes. A chip showing vet work planted in a horse for its welfare is considered an affront to "my property" and none of anyone's business. Changing the rules of the game like the Stampede has would be sent to horse racing committee hell, and might not resurface by Equestricon 2049. Unfettered university research, with a carte blanche to study our animals? Good luck.
Calgary's libertarian, agrarian, cowboy culture has so far embraced the changes, and if they can get meaningful reform done, one might suspect horse racing would too. But so far, horse racing's infighting about lasix, a reluctance to change the game, and private property issues have seemed to won the day.
Have a nice Monday everyone.
Friday, June 21, 2019
Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return
Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is
effective, in both theory and practice
In Ontario and elsewhere,
we’ve heard a lot of talk about marketing over the last several
years. The discussion is certainly a valid one. According to a 2016 CMO Survey,
US companies spend between 5% and 20% of general revenues on marketing. In the
gambling space, casinos, bingos and lottery companies can spend as much as 25%
of total revenue on marketing alone.
However, when the sport
explores a marketing plan, it often involves spending money like a Barnes and
Noble or Molson Breweries does; with commercials, giveaways, or event
marketing. Most of these tactics have been tried, and although they have
encouraged fans to visit Ontario racetracks, turning those visitors into
long-term betting customers has been elusive.
Perhaps this should not be
surprising. In today’s world, marketing is less about the sizzle and more about
the steak. Jeff Bezos, the CEO of Amazon.com, told PBS’s Charlie Rose this in
November:
"Before, if you were making a product, the right business strategy
was to put 70% of your attention, energy, and dollars into shouting about a
product, and 30% into making a great product.
The balance of power is shifting toward consumers and away from
companies, the individual is empowered. If I build a great product or service,
my customers will tell each other."
The theme that – in this new world – your product is your marketing was put a little more brusquely by venture capitalist
Fred Wilson, who recently said, “marketing is for sucky products.”
You may be thinking that if the product truly is the marketing, then harness
racing is a hard sell in the modern world. But if we look beyond the on-track
sport and concentrate on the gambling product, there is some evidence that harness
racing’s revenues can be improved, using something that can sell itself.
Enter the carryover.
Most everyone knows that a carryover is added money to a betting pool. But
understanding how and why they work is a little more complex. Basically, there
are two reasons carryovers are effective, and using a little simple betting
math we’ll explore them.
First, carryovers lower the takeout on a wager.
If a pick 4 pool has a 20% takeout and $10,000 is wagered, $2,000 is
withheld by the industry for purses and profits, and $8,000 is returned to
bettors. This happens each day, and we’re all very familiar with these bets.
Now, let’s change the mix and add a $5,000 carryover to that same pick 4 pool.
For simplicity we’ll hold constant the $10,000 the bet usually attracts.
With a simple formula (where we divide the money distributed to bettors
by the total pool) we land on an effective takeout rate. In our example - with
the new money added - the takeout is no longer 20%, but negative 30%. This
means there’s 30 cents of extra value for each dollar wagered. In gambling
parlance this is called a positive expectation pool and it’s the holy grail for
wagering customers (for any game, not just horse racing).
When
a carryover is offered, time and time again we see handle increases as bettors
chase this value.
Although carryovers and their
efficacy is a relatively new concept here in North America, overseas they’ve been
around for awhile. In Australia, for example, it was mandated by law that
blended takeout rates could not exceed 16%, and any revenue over that level had
to be returned to customers. To return the surplus betting cash they created a
0% takeout pick 4 called a “Fat Quaddie”. Australian pick 4 handle - usually in
the $200,000 range – vaulted to well over $2 million in some Fat Quaddie pools.
Australia is a more mature gambling market than North America’s, so taking
advantage of positive expectation pools was old hat for customers.
The reason the industry sees
such massive inflows of betting capital with carryovers, but much lower volumes
with guaranteed pools and jackpot carryovers, is precisely for this reason.
Guarantees are often set below what a pool usually brings in, and jackpot bets (on
non-mandatory payout days) have high takeout. In other words, carryovers have
pool value, guaranteed pools and jackpot wagers do not.
The second reason carryovers
have cache in the horseplayer world has particular relevance to harness racing:
carryovers increase pool size.
It’s no secret that unlike many
Thoroughbred tracks, harness racing pools are smaller and less viable to bet
into. It’s a problem talked about over and over again at conferences or in
track boardrooms across North America. Why small pool size is an issue is,
again, illustrated with a little bit of betting math.
Let’s
examine a pick 3 pool at a medium sized harness track; one with a pool size of
$4,000 ($3,000 after a 25% takeout). If you want three 20-1 longshots on your
ticket, the parlay payoff for that $1 bet is $9,261. If you bet into a pick 3
pool with your three 20-1 shots - and are lucky enough to hit it as a single
ticket - you are paid only $3,000. This is a ridiculous wager for anyone to
make, and dedicated gamblers will not enter the fray.
What
happens if we add a modest $2,500 carryover to this pick 3 pool? As this chart
below shows, the bet or don’t bet decision changes.
Any carryover pool should at
the very least attract money to the 0% takeout level. In this case, that’s
$10,000. Now the bettor’s 20-1 three horse parlay can pay 10,000-1, and he or
she may choose to pull the trigger. Pool size and carryovers work together, and
feed off themselves through this synergy.
At this point perhaps you’re
saying, “that’s theory, but show me reality. Is handle being increased? Do
carryovers work in Canada and the US for harness racing?”
With carryovers occurring
with some frequency, we do have some data.
In February at the
Meadowlands, a $25,000 pick 5 carryover brought in $171,000 of new money. A
week later, over $200,000 in new money was bet into a $38,000 pick 5 carryover.
Pick 5’s of this size are on par with what many large Thoroughbred tracks
achieve.
No doubt everyone in the
harness racing industry is well aware of the super high five mandatory payout
pools Woodbine has offered a few times a year. An almost $550,000 carryover
produced over $1.4 million in new money, just last month.
Because Canadian harness
racing houses several smaller tracks with modest handles (and they’re not going
to have $30,000 carryovers, or $500,000 mandatory payouts), Pompano Park is
probably a worthwhile empirical example.
This past January, a $3,400
carryover in Pompano’s 12% takeout pick 4 pool brought in $35,000 of new
money.
In February, a very small
$1,500 carryover enticed a total betting pool of over $19,000 for a super high
five wager.
In March, another super high
five pool’s $3,900 carryover attracted over $32,000 in new money.
Overall, carryover amounts
have averaged approximately $4,200 at Pompano this winter, and they’ve spurred
an approximate $25,000 average pool size. This pool size is about 400% higher
than their average in non-carryover pools.
“Regular customers know that
carryover pools can create great value. We have experimented with our wagering
menu the last few years, and some of our bets have produced carryovers. When we
offer added money there’s a real action and buzz surrounding the card – both on
social media and in the grandstand - and our customers respond with their
dollars,” noted Gabe Prewitt, Pompano Park’s Director of Racing.
Pompano has been on a bit of
a run of late. Handle has grown from $29 million to $61 million since 2014.
“Our carryover pools have definitely
been a part of our handle growth. We’re on more horseplayer’s radar,” Gabe
added.
Beyond the obvious handle
increase, there are additional accretive benefits to carryover pools. A study
by Jeff Platt of the Horseplayers Association of North America recently looked
at the benefits surrounding the promotion of the California Players Pick 5 at
Santa Anita, with 14% takeout. Although not specifically carryover related,
Jeff examined the races which comprised the pick 5 and noticed that with more
eyeballs on that one value bet, all pools increased. At the now defunct
Balmoral Park, they too noticed this phenomenon when they lowered takeout on
their pick 4 pools.
In addition to attracting new
money and adding handle across the races that make up the carryover pool, there
are other positive benefits.
Ed DeRosa, Director of
Marketing for Brisnet.com, notices strong interest across his company’s
handicapping product division when a carryover is announced.
“Non-jackpot Carryovers
are a marketers best friend. As someone who works for both racing information
and wagering websites, I can attest that telling our customers about carryovers
gets them to buy more information and wager more with it,” Ed noted via email.
Having more people involved
and interested in all facets of the product is what marketing is supposed to
do, isn’t it?
By now you may agree that
carryovers can be a good marketing avenue, but how is one manufactured; they
just happen sporadically, right? That’s true, carryovers do take some
serendipity to occur, but they can be easily created, by seeding a pool.
Seeding pools – tried before
with some success in Southern California – work exactly the same way as a
carryover. A track, not the customer, supplies the $3,000 or $5,000 for the
carryover and places it directly into the starting pool – whichever pool the
track chooses. This creates an ‘instant carryover’.
Once the seed amount and pool
are chosen (and this step is very important) this information then needs to be
filtered through the usual carryover channels. For an added boost, the bet may
be advertised via Woodbine’s HPI Bets hub, and through some American mediums,
frequented by customers.
You now have a carryover. You
have a viable betting product to promote.
This system will clearly take
planning and foresight, a budget, and some testing. Without that, seeding can
work sub-optimally, and without a doubt Grand River is not going to seed $1,000
in their pick 4 tomorrow and have it fly off the virtual betting shelves. The
track, race, day of the week, seed size amount and pool will all need to be
experimented with to see what works best. Field tests have to occur and all
hands need to be on deck in a professional way. Success, if achieved, will
likely take some time, but both the theory and empirical results are sound.
Perhaps the most exciting
characteristic of this marketing spend for the industry itself is that it’s
measurable and supplies an immediate return. As the chart below shows, for a
$5,000 seed, revenue to bet takers and the track is break-even at the $25,000
inflection point. For the track alone, the break-even handle amount is higher
($62,500), but with benchmark setting and testing, this is probably attainable.
We hear a great deal about
marketing harness racing. Often times this involves thousands of dollars in giveaways,
free parking, or radio and TV ads. Instead, why not create a pool of
marketing money and use it to invest directly into customers. If the goal of
marketing is expanding reach, getting more eyeballs on the Canadian harness
racing product, encouraging the download of handicapping materials, and
increasing handle (that provides a measurable return), seeding pools seems like
an interesting and viable option.
This article originally appeared in the Industry Issue of Trot Magazine via Standardbred Canada.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months
-
Auckland Reactor is coming to the US from New Zealand and he landed in the barn of the very sharp Kelvin Harrison. I don't think many w...
-
Have you seen the RCI's recent push to change the narrative on drugs and racing? The story they tell is accurate, and has been for some...
-
Elmer Patzer walked up to a betting machine and started popping in tickets to see if he won. All of a sudden, whamo, he cashed for $6.5 mill...
-
Yesterday on twitter there was a conversation about why some people are withholding money from Keeneland this meet. A simple question, with...
-
Back in the early 1990's I got my first real job. I was a pretty much an office gofer for a mining consortium. One day a gentleman cam...
-
Horses opening with 10k to win on them, at smaller venues lately? I have not been playing too seriously the past two days, however I did che...
-
Every time I flip on twitter someone is annoyed that NBC is tape delaying some of the events for prime time television. Columnists have join...
-
Canterbury Park - the small Minnesota track that lowered takeout last year, only to raise it this season - concluded their meet recently. Th...
-
Good morning folks. On Awful Announcing, columnist Matt Zemek tore a hide off ESPN for what he thinks is the dumbing down of tennis cover...
Similar
Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return
Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...