Sunday, February 3, 2008

Handicapping: New Player Blueprint


In part one below we spoke about several generally accepted rules for managing a gambling bankroll. In this section we will discuss in a step by step way about setting up your account and managing a small, non-professional bankroll. This is, I guess, a blueprint to hopefully become a better player, and possibly have some fun.

Most new players really get skewered. I have never played blackjack, and although I have read many books about it, I think I have played Texas holdem only a little. With those games you can play and last a little while, though. The rakes are low, and you can get on a bit of a run of luck and have some fun.

Not in racing. You can lose a bankroll in minutes. It is a tough, tough game to learn.

So, the notes below will not make you a winner. I guess if it was this easy I would be typing this from my own island on my Steve Jobs custom designed computer. Like Jeff Platt said in part one, only having a hit rate that you know is profitable can make you a winner. But hopefully I can help with giving you some tools to make the game more fun, and maybe get on the road to profitability. Remember, when players win, or have a chance to win, this game can grow. If a track isn't going to help you, someone should!

I was at WEGZ last week as I had mentioned. I sat with a couple of friends and we chatted about gambling. I asked one of them, who gambles successfully for a living, what kind of techniques a new player should tackle to hopefully preserve their bankroll, and maybe become a long-term horseplayer. I thought it would make a good attachment post to Money Management below. This is a post about what steps to take and what tools to use to become a good player. These involve: Setting up an account, your bankroll, managing that bankroll and playing to win.

Account Setup and Suggested Tools

If you want to play at the track that is fine, and there will be benefits to you here in this piece I think, but in reality playing from home can give you access to tools that you can not get live. When I play live I bring “fun money” only. The professional player who helped with this piece plays peanuts live. A double screen, a couple computers and a TV or two is his method at home (my home betting office is pictured above). So, we need an ADW like Hpibets.com, Youbet, or Premier Turf Club. If you can legally play betfair, of course that is an excellent option, because much of this piece is about win betting. When searching for an ADW first and foremost it has to be available in your jurisdiction (truly unfortunate, but that is a whole other topic). Tools I look for for an ADW to supply me with to help me win are these respectively:

Rebates: Rebates as we have discussed many times are almost essential to becoming a better player. If you blindly bet chalk you might have an ROI of 0.83. You lose 17% and that bleeds the bankroll faster than Rick Zeron can find a microphone. With a rebate this boosts ROI, boosts staying power, and gives you a better chance to be successful. If a local ADW offers you rebates, you have a better chance to succeed. I would hazard a guess that nine out of ten people who have become every day players owe this to rebates. Without them, they are dead and watching CSI on Thursday nights, instead of watching the fifth at Mohawk. This is, in my opinion, why with gambling laws changed in the US we have not seen an increase in handle as tracks' thought. People can win with an offshore rebater, at home they can not, so they quit.

Bet Tracking: There are several ADW’s out there which track bets for you. Some even let you download your stats into excel. Chances are you will have tracking that can calculate hit rate and ROI. This is vital in making you a better player. As we discussed above, knowing your hit rate helps bet size. But also, and this is really salient: All bets are not equal. You might have a good idea where or why to play place bets, or you might be an amazing exacta player. Knowing what you are good at and cutting out the bad can immediately up your ROI. If you want to keep playing your low ROI bets, well this allows you to know what you have to work on.

For me, I tracked everything and I learned a lot. My superfecta ROI was 0.54 for a period. I had no idea I was that bad. I knew I had to quit them, or improve my play. Also, I learned my ROI on show bets (when I tried some things with that) was 0.88. My win bet ROI was much higher. This made me reevaluate what in the heck I was doing with show bets. For a friend of mine who was ok at Pick 4’s, but still slightly losing, it made him realize that when WEG raised Pick 4 rakes a few years ago, he should just stop playing them, because he had no shot. These are all things that tracking can do for us as players. If your ADW does not have tracking, ask them why not (it is rumored that some tracks don’t want you to know your stats, because they feel if you saw what you lose, you would quit playing. That's great, huh?). If want to track bets by hand because your platform does not allow you this feature, try excel, or maybe ask Gordon here at Bettor Keep Track Software. I used this product for a few years. It is pretty cool and does the job.

Access to Race Replays, Webtotes and Other Tools: Some sites like HPI offer free replays. Premier Turf Club offers some awesome innovation in sending in your bets. Brisbet (now Twin Spires) has a free webtote which shows you percentage of pools to glance for overlays. If you are reading this from the UK, I don't have to tell you the huge value-added tools betfair gives you. Anything you can find that can help, go for it. You need all of the tools you can get your hands on. Some ADW's really care if you win, because they know when you win, you bet more. You bet more and they win. The ones that don't help you win, are not worth your time. [For more along these lines of what an ADW can do to help, or what their role is in the 21st century, check our chat here, with Ian of Premier Turf Club.]

Bankroll

You need a bankroll that can not be touched for anything else. You can’t buy beer, play a few slots or loan it to your friends. This bankroll should be what you can lose. No one who wants to be a serious player plays with their rent money. It’s bad news.

Money Management for a New Player

We have to bet size, and with a small bankroll this can be tricky. For example, this is what a professional player might do (touched on in Part I). He would use the Wong form of Kelly. He would bet to win a fixed amount, usually to win 1% or 2% of bankroll. If you have $20000, you’d make bets to win $200 or $400. For smaller players with $200, it is pretty tough to only bet to win $2. But, you should think like this if you can not play with a bigger bankroll: Most of us have bigger bankrolls than we think. You might bring $400 to the track, lose it all, the next night bring $250 more, and so on. Although you may only put $250 in an account, make an assumption on what your total betting bankroll is (i.e. all of your reloads). Then just play like the pro to win 1% or 2% of that total bankroll.

For example: You put $500 in Hpibets.com. But in your own head you know that you could probably stand to lose $2000 over a period of time. So you “bet to win” 1% of $2000, or $20. This is simple now. Here is an example (like we did in part I).

You like a horse at the Meadowlands in Race 1. He is 2-1 and he looks like an easy winner to you if he makes front easily. You have made him fair odds of around 6-5. You would then bet to win $20 (or 1%). You would bet $10 to get back $30, for a profit of your targeted $20. You would then do that with all other odds levels, like we explained in the Wong method in Part I. If your bankroll grows to $5000, you adjust by betting to win $50. If it falters you adjust lower. Remember the post about losing streaks? If you are betting 5-2 shots, you might have a losing streak in a normal distribution of 15. If you are betting this size with this method, you don’t go broke over 15 losses, you are still in the game to play another day.

So with this technique and bet sizing it can help avoid gamblers ruin, help you learn the game, and have some fun. It is more fun to win than lose, we all know that. If you are interested in giving this a shot I would recommend it. It won’t make you a winner, only we as gamblers can do that, but it is a building block to managing a gambling bank. I think this might be able to allow a newer or smaller player to place in $500 in an ADW, and not be have to do a dreaded reload for awhile. This gives the player time to learn on the fly, and since a couple folks have asked for my opinion on it: It is the purpose of this piece.

This touches on win betting of course, but it can go to all other forms of betting. People out there love betting for entertainment. If you want to become a serious player and learn, but have fun while going along (this is the stage I am in right now as I play with a smaller bank), there is nothing wrong with having a second account for a few pick 4’s or whatever to give you some entertainment. Don’t expect to win in that of course. If you can’t win betting win, you will have trouble winning betting exotics. This is an action bet, and folks these are considered a money-burner. But if it is a fun bankroll that you know you will lose, it does wonders for your mind. You know you have the real bankroll that you are trying to get up to many thousands, this one is inconsequential.

When I finally did most of the above several years ago, a light bulb went off and I found myself much more knowledgeable, much less emotional in my betting and much happier. This game is more fun when you have a plan, and can at least set the table to become a winner. In my honest opinion, it is night and day. You are not mad at yourself, worried about a bad trip, looking for someone to tell a sob story to, or any of the like. It is completely calming. I am so very happy I did it that way.

I hope the two previous write-ups were decent to read and they may have helped, or been informational. As I have stressed, for money management and bet sizing, you must have some idea of if you are profitable, and that takes time. Please do not take the short cuts listed above as a replacement for that. This is all for informational purposes only. What you do with it, is of your own volition and free will.

I welcome any and all comments. Good luck and good racing!

Saturday, February 2, 2008

Handicapping: Money Management Fundamentals

It has been often stated that knowing how to bet is more important than knowing what to bet. Of course that is a bit disingenuous, but after playing this game for many years I agree with it on principle.

Jeff Platt from Jcapper has a very good handicapping article on his website entitled The Sphere. Here is what he says about money management:

I’ve made no secret of the fact that my game is based around backing UDM [i.e. spot plays available to his software users] plays to win their races and that I play to a bankroll. One of the primary goals I have when I play is growing a small bankroll into a large one. Unless you are just extremely lucky the task of actually doing this takes an incredible amount of willpower. The reality is that without discipline the act of growing a small bankroll into a large one over an extended period of time is nearly impossible. Along these lines I suggest that the inexperienced player start out by going through the exercise of simply flat betting UDM plays just to get experience. After proving to yourself that you have the ability to bet UDM plays while betting nothing else, and do it profitably - then and only then try making each bet within the context of each bet being part of a bankroll. Trust me, there is no other way. Until you try you simply won’t believe how hard it can be sometimes to play a perfectly clean race day- a day where the only bets you make are UDM plays and where each bet is made at your intended percentage of bankroll.

In my experience, as we discussed a little bit below on losing streaks, a good deal of handicappers, old and new alike, are a little perplexed when speaking and learning of money management. It is like it is some weird thing that others do. It is not. We’ll try our best here to help. This will be a different piece, as well, than you usually see in handicapping books. In the second part, we will talk about money management for a newer player, or a player who wants to get better, and still enjoy the game. Most won’t touch that and it will be explained why below.

First, let’s start with an axiom which is non-negotiable, one which Jeff alludes to above. If you are a negative ROI player, money management can not help you. If you are making a bet, you need an edge, and this edge has to be positive to make the bet. If you are making a bet on a slot machine it has a negative expectation – the house always wins. If you play the slots game with betting theory, you would never make the bet.

This is why keeping track of your wagers is most important. If you do not keep track, you can not figure out your edge, and you can not properly bet size. If you do however keep track, figuring out optimum bet size based on that edge is easy. The Kelly Criterion is accepted by virtually every gambler as being accurate. It is fractional betting, not flat betting, and fractional betting involves betting your edge. If your edge is high you bet more. If your edge is low you bet less.

It works like this. You have tracked 100 bets of 3-1 shots and on these , you bet $200 and got back $230. Your ROI is 15%, or 1.15. You have a 15% edge. Now how much should I bet?

Using Kelly you divide the edge by the horses’ odds. For a 3-1 shot, for example it is 15%/3 = 5%. That means that you should bet 5% of your bankroll on this bet. If you have a bankroll of $1000, you would bet $50 to win. Most handicappers (like mentioned in the Alan Woods article that he said he did) bet fractional Kelly, 2/3rds, or one half. So if you bet with Half Kelly you would bet $25 to win. Betting half Kelly is something that helps preserve your bankroll. If you had a 50% edge and a very short shot you would be betting most of your bankroll. That is never a good thing, so half Kelly is a good thing I believe.

Now with this system you can see how it preserves your bankroll. Here is an exercise to show how: Notice what happens if you have a longshot? Let’s say your records show that on 15-1 shots (give or take 5-1) you have made a 15% ROI; then 15%/15 is 1% of bankroll. This is crucial – according to this method you do not bet the same amount on longshots as short shots. If you do, you tend to go broke, simply because the hit rate is so low. When you think about it, it does make perfect sense. I could sit here betting a flat $50 a race, with a $1000 bankroll. If I was betting 40-1 shots I might not hit a bet in 50 or 60 or even 100 or 200 bets. My bankroll would be dust before I hit one. If I was betting a flat $50 to show on 1-5 shots, conversely, I could obviously last quite awhile. This helps us survive when betting horses of different odds levels. When your hit rate is high (eg betting chalk) you can bet more, when it is low (eg betting bombs) you scale back.

The Kelly Fractional technique is generally accepted. It takes tremendous discipline however, but if we want to be better players, rather than weekend gamblers it is a lesson well learned.

Another similar method that I advocate and have been sold on, is unit betting, to figure out bet size. Stanford Wong (an associate of Alan Woods, actually in his card counting days) advocated this in his book Betting Cheap Claimers. This is how it works. You pick a number you want to win and that is your “unit”. If you want to win $100 (one unit), you can bet $100 on an even money shot (bet $100, make $100; or bet a unit to win a unit), but on a 9-1 shot you would bet $100/(odds+1) which would be 100/10 which equals a $10 bet - you would be betting 0.10 units to win a unit. This has a similar bankroll preservation result, which is what we’re after. A lot of very, very good players use this method. Wong in the book advocates that this unit betting should be used for those choosing paper bets to test their plays. I agree. If you want to try that, pick $100 as he does, and then test over a few hundred races - that is only ten days at three cards a night, and see if you come out on top. If not, go back and see what you did wrong, and so on. Soon you will see if you have a chance to have a positive ROI based on your betting angles.

We will discuss next time, what number to pick with this fractional betting idea. It is not arbitrary, it is based on bankroll size.

So there you have it - a primer on bet sizing. This does not mean much to those of you who are just starting out, or who want to try and beat the game with a bankroll, who have emailed asking about bet size. Several of you do not know your hit rate, or are playing with small bankrolls. To solve this, most books I have read seem to say “paper bet” and just experiment (like using the Wong strategy above) until you know your hit rate and edge. This is good advice of course, and I encourage it! But let’s face it, some people don’t have time and they are betting for entertainment, and just want to get marginally better. Everyone seems to want to play with real money and learn on the fly. We’ll step out of the conventional and look at that in Part II in a step by step way of becoming a regular player. It will take us through setting up an account, the bankroll, record keeping, bet size and avoiding ruin.

Friday, February 1, 2008

Friday is Guest Day: O'Brien Awards

I think Friday should be guest poster day. If anyone wants to write an opinion, for or against any of my pieces, please ask. I will post it up Fridays. Here is one I got tonight on the O'Brien Awards in Canada. A prediction on what will happen tomorrow night in the awards show featuring the best horses in the country. I thank Greg from Lucoullette.com for giving us his opinion. Greg also does some work for the Harness Edge, so go visit him there. This is a great piece and I do not think I disagree with much. Greg should be a writer :)

Here you go!

On Saturday night, Standardbred Canada is hosting the O’Brien Awards ceremony. Here are my thoughts on who should win in each category and why.

In the two-year old pacing fillies category, it’s a match-up between Shes A Great Lady winner A and Gs Confusion and OSS Super Final winner Chancey Lady. This is one of the most competitive categories this year, but I feel that A and Gs Confusion’s victories in the Shes A Great Lady and later the Three Diamonds at Woodbine should give her the nod over the talented Casie Coleman pupil.

The two-year old colt and gelding pacer is between Santanna Blue Chip and Somebeachsomewhere. Any other year, Santanna Blue Chip would be an absolute slam dunk based on his victories in the Governor’s Cup and Breeder’s Crown, but anybody who watched Somebeachsomewhere win in 1:49.3 at Mohawk cannot possibly vote against the Mach Three colt.

The two-year old filly trot and two-year colt and gelding trot categories are both no contests. Snow White might be the best two-year old trotter in history, period, and Windsong Espoir finished the year undefeated, including a victory in the William Wellwood at Mohawk. Bella Dolce and Surtees Hanover are both very nice horses, but picked the wrong year to race against these two.

On the three-year old side, Hana Hanover should claim top three-year old pacing filly over Michelles Power. Hana Hanover went to the Meadowlands and upset Southwind Tempo in the Mistletoe Shalee and was a consistent cheque-getter in all the big races after that. Michelles Power had a great run at Mohawk, including a victory in the Simcoe in 1:50.1, but tailed off after that.

Three-year old filly trotter should go to Pampered Princess. Her connections raced her against the boys several times this year with mixed results, but she also won the Elegantimage and a stake at Lexington to help her earn over $1 million this season. Brigham Dream had a great year in Quebec and the Ontario Sires Stakes program for trainer J.P. Dubois, but didn’t test any of the grand circuit stakes.

Tell All will take the three-year old pacing colt and gelding award over OSS Super Final champion Bigtime Ball. Tell All was fantastic in winning the North America Cup and then also took the Little Brown Jug for trainer Blair Burgess. Bigtime Ball, a brother to Invitro, had a nice year in the OSS , but struggled with breaks at many points during the year.

Arch Madness did an unbelievable job this year for trainer Trond Smedshammer, and will be rewarded with the trophy for three-year old trotting colts and geldings. He had a great year in the OSS program, including winning the Super Final, and then upset Donato Hanover in both the elimination and final of the Breeders Crown to cement his place as the winner. His competitor, Val Taurus, had a very good year again in Quebec , and won an elimination of the Canadian Trotting Classic, but made a break in the final.

In the older trotting mare category, I believe Mystical Sunshine will get the nod. She’s a gritty and versatile trotting mare, as she won the Breeders Crown at Mohawk and then went to the Delaware County Fair and won the Ms. Versatility final in 1:53.2. Snazzy Millie is a nice mare that often gets overlooked because she races against the boys so often, but she did win the Ontario Masters Series at Georgian.

Older trotting horse is a real toss-up for me. The horse that probably should win, Equinox Bi, only had two starts in the country, so he was not eligible. I would give Vivid Photo the trophy based on his second to Equinox Bi in the Maple Leaf Trot and his third to Equinox Bi in the Breeders Crown. J M Vangogh won the Earl Rowe and the Ontario Masters Series, but didn’t participate in the top tier trotting events that Vivid Photo did.

Older pacing mare should be easily taken by Moving Pictures. This Casie Coleman pupil went on a tear at Mohawk this past summer, winning the Roses Are Red, Milton and Breeders Crown at the Campbellville oval. Darlins Delight had another good year, but is no match here.

Mister Big had a fantastic year, and should take the older pacing horse category. Mister Big won the Willowdale at Woodbine in January and was still going into July and August when he won the William Haughton Memorial and then the US Pacing Championship in 1:47.4. Lis Mara, who was probably picked to win not only this category but Horse of the Year going in, had an up and down year and played second fiddle to Mister Big more than Mister Big did to Lis Mara.

Onto the human awards, where I think Mark Steacy will take the horsemanship award over Phil Pinkney. Pinkney is a very underrated trainer from the Maritimes, who does a great job, but Steacy kept Hana Hanover going all year and then won another Breeders Crown with Stylish Artist.

Breeder of the Year should go to Tara Hills Stud. Tara Hills sire Kadabra completely dominated the Ontario Sires Stakes program with his two-year olds, and they also bred Stylish Artist.

Driver Of The Year will go to Jody Jamieson over Paul MacDonell. Jody had a fantastic year, driving horses like Tell All and Santanna Blue Chip. He finished second by a narrow margin in the WEG driver standings and earned over $10 million.

Trainer Of The Year will once again go to Casie Coleman, who not only dominated the WEG trainer standings again, but also won her first Breeders Crown, in addition to several other stakes victories. Blair Burgess had another fantastic year, but if he didn’t win last year when he had three stakes stars, I don’t believe he will win this year, either.

Finally, Horse Of The Year should go to Somebeachsomewhere, but don’t be surprised if Tell All or Arch Madness wins.

Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months

Similar

Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return

Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...