Sunday, March 10, 2013

Quality, McKinsey and Reality

The McKinsey Report for racing a couple of years ago made some recommendations. One of them was that 'top quality racing' was of importance, because that's what people want to see.

On the surface this makes perfect sense.

Yesterday at Tampa Bay Downs, the Tampa Bay Derby was bet to the tune of about $2 million, and they had a card that was attended, and bet, with over $10 million going through the tote for the day.

Bravo.

When one looks deeper into the quality argument it's not the answer that's an issue, it's that we're answering the wrong question. It'd be great to have a Tampa Bay Derby day everyday - at Beulah, or The Meadowlands or Charles Town - then we'd have 'quality' racing. But we can't.

There are over 80,000 races a year in standardbred and thoroughbred racing, and they can't all be quality. For about 79,500 races a year we need to look at a different measure, or the industry would crumble. Billions of dollars a year are provided from 98% of the races that can never be all 'quality'.

In HRU today (pdf) the entire quality argument was looked at from an end user and revenue perspective.
  •  If we really want the "quality" everyone seems to speak of, then run a few thousand races a year like they do in the UK, or a few hundred or so like they do in Hong Kong. Of course we can't do that because the result would be the implosion of the North American racing industry.
  • Quality in harness racing, or racing in general, should be looked at in only one fashion, and that is how the end user consumes the product.
  • Right now out of the many thousand races run a year, probably three quarters of them are unbettable. Racing must work at eliminating the unbettable and replacing them with the bettable, and it is in their power to do so.
Give it a read and let me know what you think.

Have a great Sunday everyone.

Friday, March 8, 2013

A Little Meat on the Bone in Ontario For Racing

Today's presser with the Premier and some of racings participants at Grand River Raceway in Elora was expected to be a bit of a snoozefest, however, it was a little more than advertised.

The Premier announced deals with four tracks for transition money and relayed she is fully behind the transitional panel's recommendation of integrating the OLG plan with horse racing.

The first part of that announcement is a band aid, the second part is perhaps most important, because it involves certain possibilities that can achieve long term growth.

They may or may not include:
  • A stand alone casino at Woodbine
  • A horse racing lottery
  • Sports betting at racetracks
  • New avenues to up the bet in Ontario
  • And OLG/Racing gaming partnership, where it is run not unlike a PMU or Sweden ATG
I don't know how many emails and protracted conversations I have had with people saying "this is not enough, we need slots" or "that won't support 1500 racedates, we need slots back to get 1500 racedates", "we want slots back" and so on. But the simple fact, just like it was a fact last year around this time my answer was the same: Slots are not coming back, the status quo has long left the building, so why bother even talking about it.

And knowing that, the above announced today is probably better than anyone could've hoped for. It is infinitely better than what was proposed 12 months ago.

And it solidifies this salient fact: Ontario is not New Jersey, and thank god it isn't.

There the rug was pulled under racing, and they were given one year of 'casino subsidy money' totalling peanuts then told "don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out". We saw an "elite meet" at Monmouth, then a struggle. We saw terrible card after terrible card at the Meadowlands, where it could've become a parking lot.  The industry is decimated beyond belief there.

In Ontario the industry will be smaller, of course. You can't take $345 million away from something and have it be bigger, or anywhere near the size it was. There is a chance, however, and it is more than a fluttering chance or one that's remote, that the industry can start to be rebuilt.

Ontario won't be New Jersey. And Ontario of today isn't the "don't let the door hit you" Ontario of one year ago. That's a good thing. 


Lasix, Brand Ambassadors & Betting

Lasix use or non-use is one of the more interesting debates in horse racing. Bacon yesterday interviewed a vet who took the pro-lasix side and did a fairly good job explaining it. It was weird reading it though, because as a dude who doesn't much like the drug on horses, I got the feeling he was telling me I was a horse abuser for having that view. 
  •  Studies have demonstrated that approximately 60% of the sudden deaths during racing have been attributed to pulmonary hemorrhage, EIPH grades of 2 or more have been shown to adversely affect racing performance, and EIPH is believed to adversely affect the overall health of racehorses.  We know that EIPH is pathology, an injury to the lung of the horse, and that this injury causes further lung pathology.  
Since he lumps in standardbreds with thoroughbreds, one might think the thousands upon thousands of harness horses with 300 or more lifetime starts and thousands more training miles without using lasix were thrown to the wolves and put at great risk.  It's tough to buy that argument. It just doesn't seem to wash.

I guess the use of old time horsemen treatments, adjunct meds and the like have helped good trainers not use lasix and especially for harness horses that does make sense. Racing once per week, having the crap kicked out of your horse every seven days by dehydrating him or her, having him lose weight, put it on and then do it all over again is problematic. Maybe that's why thoroughbreds race so sparingly, I do not know. But it is a path that good harness trainers take with their stock - whether it be a 5 claimer or a $5 million dollar racehorse. I hardly think they are putting their horses "at great risk".

The way I have always looked at the lasix debate is how I look at any other. Plenty of pedestrians are killed in big cities each year. If we mandate they wear a suit of armor it will save lives. If you are against such a thing someone might call you a pedestrian death supporter. But the loss of rights, freedoms and common sense would trump that policy, and it would not happen. I have little doubt that lasix stops bleeding in racehorses, but treating a horse for it, using some adjunct meds and herbs and everything they use overseas lessens that risk just fine, it seems. On the flipside, the gains from not having the drug in a racing program each day, or not having a Drapian "needle plunging into a neck" 4 hours before every race has some benefit as well.

No matter where you are on the lasix debate, sky is falling truisms are rarely the most accurate way to approach understanding the debate.  A little pro and con common sense can go a long way.

There is plenty of chatter on the interwebs about the Brand Ambassador program started by the NTRA/Jockey Club/America's Best Racing. A bunch of dudes and dudettes are going on a bus tour promoting racing. Teresa wrote about it in Forbes this week. 

The current meme (not surprising, because people have watched many racing marketing ideas fail) is that "it's a stupid idea" but I don't know enough about it either way to say so or not. Maybe it will work, who knows. What I do think is that i) results will be hard to measure and ii) We're selling branding, and the way racing is set up revenue-wise, that's a whole can of worms.

Across the pond in the UK there is a similar program going on.
  • The aim of Great British Racing will be to broaden the appeal of British horse racing at every level, with the objective of increasing participation and revenues, and protecting and growing the thousands of jobs that exist within the sport.
This makes a little more sense over there, not because of the program, but where revenue comes from in the UK. About 30% of racings revenues are sponsorship there, and that is measurable. Here in North America a few tracks have embraced sponsorship like Woodbine and Charles Town, but as a rule, revenue is betting revenue. 

Racing is in a very tough spot with marketing in North America. We need to sell correctly and right, but we also need something to sell, along with a measurable sales channel to see what's working or not working.

Last up, betting sure is frustrating, but when things get that way, more often than not you can blame yourself and yourself only. Not only do you need the right horses, you need the right preparation.

Yesterday I liked two $40 horses at Oaklawn that were in the pick 4 sequence. A $50 and a $25 winner at the Meadowlands that was in that pick 4 sequence. A 24-1 shot at Fairgrounds that was in the super high 5 carryover, with a 4-5 shot who always hits the board in the same race.

By simply messing up my ticket planning, I ended up with very little off those plays.

If you are going to the track to play win and win only, life is easy. See a horse, see his odds, look at him on the track and bet or don't bet. With exotics you really need to spend time with your plays. If not, you end up frustrated.

The people who think we can get slots players over to play horse racing I don't think have ever played horse racing. A more intricate and interesting gambling game you will not find.

Have a great Friday everyone!

Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months

Similar

Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return

Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...