Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Racing's Love & Hate Relationship With Technology

Alex Waldrop tweeted out a story on Fantasy Sports which I referenced this morning. A commenter on the blog left the following:

"It cost an arm and a leg to build a racing database" - Don't think it's that expensive with the new technology. Average out the cost per racetrack per year it's not that expensive and would have huge benefits."

In the 1990's I played quite a bit of fantasy football with many of my University pals. I would get most of my data from the web to draft and field my team, and there was one site I frequented which had box scores back to the 1970's. One day I was chatting with a friend who was a programmer, with the hopes of scraping that box score data, placing it in a database and making the website searchable for fantasy football team managers.

I checked into the legalities of it, my programmer friend built his fancy data scraping tool, and away we went. Everything was fine. Not long after, my friend got a high paying job which turned his eight hour workdays to sixteen hour ones, and with a baby on the way, it died on the vine. The point was clear, though. It was not difficult or costly to create and promote fantasy stats and useful information to users.

Only a few years later many of these sites were taking hold and the NFL was more than happy to oblige. These sites were promoting the game of football to the masses, and it wasn't costing the NFL a dime. A couple of them were worth some money, too. I think we were on the right track.

In the early 2000's I shifted some of my thought for these ancillary activities to horse racing. I noticed there was a website that was scraping published harness race results and running lines from the web, and compiling it into a database. This is exactly what had been done in fantasy football. I contacted the owner, with the hope of creating software to look through old race results, build some models, look at trainer stats and the like, to get an edge on my betting. Or maybe even sell the software.

He noted that the industry was after him for scraping results. Even though the lines were published, just like a box score in a newspaper, and he was only republishing them in a user-friendly way, there was some sort of dispute. Not long after, his website was shut down.

I didn't want to give up, so I called around finding out how I could get this data. I wanted to do something with it: Try and model it, handicap better, hopefully make money, build a website, who knows. I asked how I could get few years of running lines on my computer - remember this is not asking for the world, this is asking for a few gigabytes of text that was already published for free and hosted on the web. The answer was that it would "probably cost more than $5,000".

I could not scrape it and use it as I wanted, just as thousands of fantasy football fans were doing with box scores, but it seems could pay $5,000 or more for it.

After that I would have to pay someone to build me a piece of software, and keep buying lines (not figs, nothing, just running lines). I expected this to cost me $10,000 or more, and I had no idea if it would even work.

I'd had enough at that point and figured it was not worth my while. I shifted my pursuit of handicapping to the thoroughbreds.

The chasm between trying to build a football database and a horse racing one was as wide as the Grand Canyon. One was fast, easy and welcoming. The other was difficult, strange and a "don't let the door hit you on the way out" experience. I had trouble with it, because I was wanting to give the industry thousands upon thousands of dollars a year in takeout revenue, and it was like I had the plague.

Racing has always had a love hate relationship with technology. It's not like any other industry I know of, except maybe the music industry, who gloriously messed up the early years of digital music.

When online stock brokers entered the realm, they jumped in with both feet. They created an interface and software that could make your head spin. They invested and reinvested millions and completed changed the stock buying and selling culture. As well, they offered their services at a low price. In the 1970's it cost $300 to make a trade, and you did it while calling a broker. Now, trades were $8 and you did it with a mouse.  The benefits of the Internet are low prices and harnessing technology to make for an easier, more pleasurable customer experience. Without both of those we probably would not be watching an E*Trade baby (although that might not be a bad thing).

Racing didn't quite jump in with both feet, in fact they barely jumped in at all.

Perhaps the best technology company in racing is Twinspires, through CDI. They invested and reinvested in technology, they've done the things (yes, I know it took awhile) that online poker sites and places like Betfair have done. But they've never embraced the price angle. They are like an E*trade who still charges $300 a trade. 2013 technology, 1973 pricing.

Most of the changes in racing are slow, and have to pass muster with myriad groups. To this day it is not uncommon to see a horsemen group person, or persons, say some nasty things about Twinspires. It's not uncommon to see taxes wanted to be placed on online bettors, like they're doing something wrong. It's not at all uncommon to see the meme, "these guys are pirates that take people away from the track". That's the same thing some NFL owners said in 1960 about television. Thankfully - for the NFL - they were outvoted.

How about exchange wagering? My goodness if you mention Betfair in some places in racing you'd think they were a bunch of Brits who punch babies.

States like Texas and Arizona (along with their horsemen groups) don't much care for online betting, either. The people who stand against betting racing online probably downloaded five songs on iTunes and bought their wife a new DVD from Amazon.com last week. That's fine of course.

From these same people you'll sometimes hear complaints like "racing has to get with the times with new technology". How can they do that if you don't let them?

It's love hate and it's been that way for a long, long time. If a fiefdom sees some immediate monetary benefit from technology they love it. If that technology is growth oriented but disruptive, they hate it. It's one of the reasons I think racing cannot keep up with other games and sports. We've spent our time arguing about technology based on whom it may affect or whom it may not, while the world around us was embracing it.


L, Glorious Dirt, Sid & Joe

Here are some items which crossed the virtual desk that I found kind of interesting.....

There was a neat story by the Baconater on his site about the machinations of the Breeders Cup lasix ban, er not ban.
  • The board came within an eyelash of rolling back the Lasix ban for all races.
In horse racing when the going gets tough, the tough get going ..... to the nearest exit to reverse policy.

I think it's a testament that big money owners and trainers have a lot of say in this game, and no one can really set rules that stand up to them. In Ontario when the whipping ban was enforced, drivers went completely nuts. There were similar claims: It was unsafe, it would cause a boycott, etc. But the Commission here held firm and never wavered. Three years later those claims were clearly hyperbole, but that's neither here nor there, I guess. I figure if a few giant stables and a couple of big owners didn't like it, we might've not seen the whipping ban either.

Anyhoo, I agree with O Crunk who wrote:
There's a new editor at the DRF, Mark Simon. I read the story in the Journal yesterday about companies using data to hire people. Some will ask questions on an application and try and figure out of the candidate fits. I wonder if the DRF uses questions, too.

Dirt or synthetic?

Easy Goer or Sunday Silence?

East coast or west coast?

I kid, I kid.

Alex Waldrop tweeted out this story on Fantasy Sports today.  For the folks who say racing is failing because it is "too complicated" they have trouble explaining fantasy sports. Fantasy sports works because it's a) available b) has free data for you to study and c) has an outcome that's in front of you each time you watch a game from your couch. Racing has done a poor job with a (residency requirements and home market areas) b (it costs an arm and a leg to build a database) and c (for years video was behind some sort of Fort Knoxian firewall).

Kawartha Downs has shut down. I think we'll see most private tracks in Ontario go the way of the do do bird, while the Ag tracks will stay. I don't think - since the industry must shrink to survive with less money - that would be a bad thing. The tracks that have a shot to grow are the Ag tracks. They'll be on-board with new ideas, and new investment; much more so than the for profit ones. The new Ontario will be about asset allocation.

I was totally bummed yesterday that Mike Bloomberg's plan to make you buy two cups to drink 32 ounces of coke instead of one was struck down by the courts. His incredible fact finding, scientific study that fat people consume more calories than skinny people did not sway the judge much. I am not overly concerned about it, since I only travel to New York and don't drink gallons of soda, but I am really bummed because my first foray into short story writing here on the blog will not happen.

I have it on good intel that Sid Fernando and Joe Drape (despite some dust ups on twitter, which I am sure is done to throw me off the case) meet in Park Slope once a week to discuss racing. There, they don't have a beer, but share a 2 litre bottle of Jolt Cola. I was waiting in the weeds for the Pop Police to come and bust them and send them to Rikers.

While in the Big House, Sid (because his various Apple products are taken away) goes into deep meditative thought, and Joe learns to play the harmonica. Through music and Tibetian introspection, they solve racings problems, and when they are released they go on a traveling road show to tell anyone who wants to listen. In the end, Joe and Sid are named Co-Racing Commissioners, handle explodes, people buy yearlings for millions each day, and racing is saved.

Now, because of this judge, the above will not happen. The judge must not like horse racing.

Have a great Tuesday everyone!


Monday, March 11, 2013

Culture Change at the M, Derby Math & Derby Horses

This weekend I did some handicapping at the Meadowlands and it felt like old times. In two races the "Meadowlands shuffle" was alive and well. Several of the races were barnburners, with horses coming from everywhere.

For a harness racing fan, it was second to none.

About one year ago Jeff Gural, the Meadowlands owner, heard loud and clear from bettors and fans that the new Meadowlands wasn't like the old Meadowlands. There were too many holes, too many races which looked like pre-determined, buddy-buddy affairs. Instead of sitting on his hands, he asked the drivers and trainers to race, not just show up. The judges were watching the racing for holes given, and the inevitable "pull and wait for cover" that accompanied it. The result has been apparent.

Racing is very cultural. Whipping rules can't change because 'that's the way we drive'. Change can't happen because of tradition. Takeout can't be lowered because 'we've always had high takeout'. Some might think the way drivers drove at the Meadowlands the last five years or so could not be changed either. But it was, and racing is better for it.

Speaking of the Meadowlands, Saturday, Bob DiNozzi, a part time trainer who never wins a race, won a race driving his own horse. And paid $103.  There is a constant debate on chat boards or twitter about who means more, a driver or a jockey. My answer is always jockey, simply because a dude like Bob DiNozzi can win races without too much problem, while I can't see Doug O'Neill hopping aboard one and doing the same. :)

Staying on the rider angle, a riderless Fort Larned absolutely smoked the field at Gulfstream on the weekend (don't worry, he's okay). We've seen riderless horses time and time again win a race, but it is usually by a small margin. Fort Larned literally was up by 150 yards. I know the poor fella might've been spooked and was running on fear, but that was absolutely amazing. Interestingly, if he is a short price next time, I might play against him off the bounce angle.  I mean that was some crazy-ass speed.

Warrawee Needy lost on Saturday, but it was not by lack of trying. He was a fade for me, as I thought Mark Mac should not have had to go to the whip last week off those splits, knowing how great he is fresh. But that was (even though he lost) a wrong play. The horse was really good, and if he can settle he should be more than fine for next week, in my opinion.

What happened to commenting on Standardbred Canada? I expected plenty of concerned comments after the Premier spoke on Friday, but crickets. 

The Racing Beard is back. Decent site for harness fans.

I guess I should mention Varazzano. I really don't know what to say because commenting how much I liked the move Eskendreya made in the Wood, or how great Uncle Mo looked two years ago, or how I was stoked to see Quality Road's year after his spring 120 Beyer, never gets me anywhere. For a lot of horses I am going to wait until Derby Day to make a judgement.

As for the race in California this weekend, I did not see it. It's weird but since the rake hike I have not paid the slightest attention to the racing out there. It's become a habit to not look at a PP, or watch a race, so I did not even know when the race was happening (I thought it was on Sunday for some reason). It's not me being cheeky either, it's because there are lots of other tracks to play, and I just don't have time to watch races at a track I am not betting. Regardless, I got my news on the affair via the video report by Mark Doche here; and it was a nice report. Worth a watch. 

If you are annoyed with your Derby horse draft, maybe you should change it up next year and take a prep pool where you get the horse who wins the prep, places in the prep or shows in the prep. Maybe the Florida Derby would go first overall, but you might grab the Sunland Derby winner in the fourth round and get lucky. 

I think Churchill is making an error not allowing Betfair to have a Derby market. Betfair has 3 million customers, and some of them will only watch the Derby to trade it, or play it in running. It harkens me back to the poker story, where shutting down online poker was supposed to help poker. Instead, online poker players just found something else to do.

I still remember watching my favorite in-running Derby. Street Sense was 10-1 because he looked like he would get blocked on the inside move. Bettors were saying that Calvin was going to be a goat, but instead he was Superman.

Derek Simon, one of the smarter bettors out there, looked at the effectiveness of Derby trainers via an expectation formula. Some of the results (the Toddster) might not surprise you, but some (Zito, Mott) might.

Greg Blanchard - truly one of the very good guys in this sport - was featured in a London newspaper.

Driver loyalty was featured in last month's Trot. You can read it here.

To make money at racing long-term, you have to land on horse's that other people aren't landing on. That's why visually impressive wins, or trouble trips for beaten chalk are the worst bets in modern horse racing.  A guy who lands on horse's with some bad lines is Inside the Pylons on twitter. I notice we rarely like the same horse but yesterday we both landed on a horse at Tampa in the last and tweeted it. Maybe, just maybe we're sitting on a nice winner to make a score? Not likely. The horse was eased. As the kids say, I LOL'd.
Who needs her. Talking phones are a fad anyway. 

Have a great Monday everyone.

Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months

Similar

Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return

Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...