Friday, March 15, 2013

Making Sausage

Good morning racing fans!

In the NFL they began looking into changing the helmets recently. The league wants lighter, safer helmets, with sensors built in them, to look at sensory data in game situations. In major sports, or any business really, policy, rules, safety issues and the like are looked at discussed and changed. It's usually done quickly, with a CEO-led approach.

In racing, of course, it's not quite like that. The discussion goes on and on and on and on, and nothing really changes much.

If changing a helmet was like changing a racetrack surface, we'd have people talking about soft tissue neck injuries, the tradition of the modern helmet, or the fact that players - since about age eight - only know how to play in one type of helmet and it is unfair to ask them to try a new one.

There'd be stories on the Ham and Egg Football report asking overseas football players about the softer helmets. A football player would be interviewed on a pro anti-safe helmet website saying how much he doesn't like it. A bespectacled trainer for a big market team would give interviews saying the helmet will cause him problems. Data would be taken from one game where a one player on one play turned his head to tackle - because according to him he didn't feel right playing in it and it changed his game - and he got a stinger. That would be used to say how stupid the new helmet idea was.

It is similar with rule changes, that happen every year and we're seeing talked about this year in the NFL. There might be squawking, but in the end it all works out, like the clothesline rule 30 years ago. It won't go on for years.

Sausage making in regular sports or business is  not made like it is in racing. It's made behind the scenes. The science is discussed by a steering committee with smart people, and it takes some time. Then the CEO decides if the policy makes sense, is workable, is implemented, or not implemented. Then it is or it isn't. The sausage is made by people who know how to make it, then it's sent to market.

Racing makes their sausage in the opposite way. The process is filled with commentary from a lot of people who have no idea how to make sausage. The ingredients, the machine, and the people who are selected to make it are rarely ever even assembled. In the end the sausage is not likely ever brought to market, but even if it is, it's not edible.

Notes:

Yesterday's Harness Racing Update (pdf) was excellent. It had full coverage of Rock n Roll Hanover's death with quotes from many, like former trainer Brett Pelling.

Also in the pub, Bill Finley looked at Gural's letter asking for entries, and tore a hide off that, in a pretty interesting way. His last line in the article was thought provoking as well. What if the M gets slots? Would Gural say "you're not welcome here because you didn't support me when we needed you."

Fantastic article on Lasix by Joe in VFTRG yesterday. He goes through its politics, its history, and exposes it for what it's really about: Money. To think there was a time where horses who bled badly were not allowed to race. Some of the same people today who say it's cruel to not allow lasix were the same people asking for the bad bleeder exclusion policy of the past to be reversed. Common sense has left the building, and reading the commentary out there, it's not close to returning.

Finley looked at Verrazano at ESPN this week, with thoughts from Jerry Browne at Thorograph. Having a horse so on his toes, so primed, so sharp and so ready for his first start is the way of the modern trainer - in thoroughbred or harness racing. It just was not like this years ago.

We see the awful early death of Rock n Roll Hanover, but it reminds us of his trainer - Brett Pelling. Pelling could train a thoroughbred or a standardbred or a quarterhorse. He was, in my opinion, as good a horseman at knowing  how to train and manage a horse that there ever was or is. He always had his stakes colts peak, and last an entire year. Rock n Roll Hanover qualified in 1:55 and raced his first tilt in 1:54 only seven years ago. He raced five or six seconds faster about five or six times after that, in big races. This past year, no fewer than 10 colts qualified four seconds quicker. None of them were near as good, or raced as soundly as Rock did. The modern trainer, in my opinion, can learn a lot from Brett Pelling.

Have a great day everyone.


Thursday, March 14, 2013

Death of a Champ

Rock n Roll Hanover (26-15-5-5 $3,069,063) died today at the age of 11, after complications in surgery.

The son of Western Ideal out of the super mare producer Rich n Elegant was more than just a tremendous racehorse, he was an all world sire. This is a huge loss for harness racing and for his current owners, Perretti Farms. As most know, Perretti has had some tough times of late being situated in New Jersey, where the Governor and other pols pulled the rug out from under racing a few years ago.

I remember first seeing Rock n Roll at the Metro Pace eliminations at Woodbine. he was a looker, but as a handicapper I sure wasn't sold. He paced a 27.4 third quarter wide, and came home in 27.1 in that elim, which was pretty sparkling, but I still wasn't sold. That was a mistake, as he won the $1,200,000 race in a World Record 1:49.4 and paid boxcars.  You never got those odds on him again.

In the age of lighting up horses for their 3 year old debuts, it might come as a shock to remember Rock's first start at three when he won off cover in 154 and change. From there he demolished fields in the North America Cup and Meadowlands Pace. He finished the year a dominating winner in the Breeders Crown.

After retirement he became a super sire. His sons and daughters are too many to mention in one column. 

I never owned a Rock n' Roll yearling, although I always wanted to. Maybe this year. He was one of my favorite horses.

IHA Should be KIA

Bill Oppenheim wrote an absolutely dandy piece in the TDN yesterday (pdf) about the debate and obfuscation of the Breeders Cup decision on lasix. In the piece he examines the veto power and machinations of the 1978 Interstate Horse Racing Act that leads up to stand offs such as this.
  • Also a factor was that, in 2011, when the Board created the new race-day medication policy, TOBA's Graded Stakes Committee attempted to follow suit, and there were initiatives by The Jockey Club and in various states to ban race-day medication. Ultimately all these initiatives foundered on the same rock--the 1978 Interstate Horseracing Act which made simulcasting across state lines legal, also included provisions requiring consent (in most states) by Aauthorized horsemen's groups. Once the horsemen discovered they really did have veto power, the game was up.
Steve Zorn took exception to this and noted on his blog:
  •  Oppenheim finds the root of all evil in Section 3004 of Title 15 of the United States Code – the section of the Interstate Horse Racing Act of 1978 (IHA) that gives local horsemen’s group a veto power over simulcast signals to and from their tracks.  In Oppenheim’s view, the aristocrats of the racing world, embodied in the Jockey Club, the Breeders Cup Board and the TOBA Graded Stakes Committee, were all set to save US racing by eliminating the use of Lasix, when those pesky horsemen discovered that the IHA gave them veto power. 
As with most things in horse racing: You're wrong, I'm right, take that. Then we go back to the status-quo blankie, where we feel safe. 

I think both of them are probably right. Oppenheim is completely correct an act written in 1978 in a world where racing now competes with lotteries, internet betting, poker and everything else is obsolete. Zorn is right that you and I who buy horses can't be walked on like a doormat.

Updating the IHA to reality, i.e. present day 2013, would be warranted.

Having a horsemen group give a yeah or nay with veto power if a track wants to, for example, lower takeout or change a betting product to compete is not the way the IHA was intended to function. But that's what we see today. A track might work on a business plan to do something big to grow, and in one meeting - no more than 10 minutes long perhaps - a couple of fellas across the table can say no. That's that.

What's worse, in some jurisdictions the relationship between tracks and a horsemen group can be so acrimonious, even when something good is proposed, it's rejected because of that dislike. We saw a bit of that in Ontario when a horsemen group was finally replaced by the rank and file at Woodbine. The damage was already done, though.

That's crazy, or as the kids say 'cray cray'.

No one is saying they don't have a say, they should. What I'm saying is, when GM wants to set the price of their new car they're building they use market research, economists and others to do that. The guy who makes the rubber for the tires in Akron can't say "no".

Conversely, it doesn't mean the rank and file has no power. If GM wanted to slash wages by 50% and cut a half a million people, the union does have recourse. They have to, with economists, hard data and a business case show why their way is better. This might go to an arbitrator to be solved.

In California we are seeing a bit of this now with the pick 5, and did a few years ago with the takeout hike. The tracks have made a wonderful case about the pick 5 - how it grows handle in each of the races in the sequence, how the lower rake has worked and so on. The TOC can just say no. They don't have to make a business case. They don't really have to do anything. There's a good chance this bet will be scrapped, where everyone is a loser.

For those of you on Andy's California email list, he put it this morning this way relating it to a Mike Pegram McDonald's: 'A chicken farmer doesn't tell him what price his McNuggets should be'

For simulcast agreements or expansions, no business case, no arbitrator, nothing has to occur. A horseman group can just say "no" and hundreds of thousands of customers can be screwed.

All because an IHA was written for a different time, in a different world.

The world has changed. The gambling landscape is 180 degrees different than it was 35 years ago. The urbanization of North America and their view on how animals are treated for human gain is looked at 180 degrees differently than it was 35 years ago.

This business must change. It's handcuffed to do so by well meaning, but ineffective acts of 35 years ago. For horse racing to move forward, I believe the IHA must be changed. Not eliminated, but changed to reflect the world we live in.

Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months

Similar

Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return

Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...