In the spring of 2010, Los Alamitos decided to try and increase revenues for purses by raising the takeout. Their horse population was not stout and they didn't much want to drop a day a week to get purses and field size up (the easiest way to increase a purse, or handle 'per race' is drop a day, but it doesn't grow the pie, generally). This was a last ditch attempt to get that done.
It was passed as a "temporary measure", where if handle or revenue looked to be hurting, they would review the policy and revert back to the old takeout rate that fall. It was also a test case for raising takeout at all thoroughbred tracks in the State.
As the following graph, prepared by USC economist Caroline Betts, showed back in 2010, it was probable the takeout increase was having an affect:
It appeared the initial news about the takeout increase filtered the horseplayer information channels like Paceadvantage.com, HANA and elsewhere. There was a decrease rather quickly. However, the data is noisy, especially when we factor in they ended up dropping a day a week anyway. Instead of racing 4 days a week they were racing three.
This noise was relayed to the CHRB during the review. The "average handle per race" angle was talked about. As well, the initial decrease was blamed on other things (yes, I know this sounds silly) like the Vancouver Olympics. Horseplayers argued at the meeting that the plan looked like it was doing more harm than good. In the end they voted to keep the price hike, and continued to decrease payouts to customers who cashed tickets. Later in 2010, they voted to expand this policy to the thoroughbred tracks in the state.
I've always believed a takeout increase is not felt immediately. Sure there's the negative buzz and bad PR, and that does decrease some handle, but horseplayers are creatures of habit. Some will happily keep playing. I believe here is where the effect is felt: Over time they have less money back to bet, this causes them to have more betting low's than high's, and it is deleterious.
It's not unlike the opposite of a slot machine. Casino's know that they have to give back a lot of money, because sitting at a machine that eats all your money in ten minutes is not much fun. They give back enough to keep the users brain happy, thinking they are winning when they aren't. In horse racing, dripping bankrolls act the same, and if the faucet drips more, the player has less money and less fun. Some end up leaving the game forever.
I went through some handle charts yesterday to see if any of this took place. Although it is hard to say for sure, I think there is ample evidence that says it has.
Before the rake hike, handle per week (4 cards) was about $4.4 million, or somewhere around $1.1 million per card. Immediately after the rake hike (still in 2010), handle per week (3 cards) was about $3.8 million or about $1.25 million per card. This makes sense because when you cut a day a week, field size goes up, and horseplayers (mainly fixed) bankrolls are spread across fewer races. One horse more per race equals somewhere around a 5% handle bump.
Fast forwarding to today almost three years later, I looked at a few snapshots (this is not scientific, just a few race days). For three days at the median in January, the results are:
Gross handle for the week: $3.18 million
Handle per card: $1.06 million
This is well down from 2009/2010, for both the pre and post takeout hike periods. Horse racing mostly uses the economy when handle goes south, but that is problematic here. The economy is still bad yes, but it's better than 2010, and with the rate of inflation alone, handle should be up, not down.
The other interesting thing I noticed is average on track handle. On track handle pays full boat, and over time this should fall with a rake increase. At Los Al this may have happened.
As shown in Ms. Betts' chart above, before the takeout increase, on track handle was about $500,000 per week, or $125,000 per card.
In the three day snapshot I looked at, on track handle was $266,062 for the week or $88,267 per card. That's about a 30% reduction per raceday.
I am the first to admit that these numbers are not the be all and end all via the takeout increase. They are also only a small snapshot. There are many things that go into handle increases, and growing or reducing the pie. There have been many changes in racing since 2010, of course, including rebating (which lowers takeout and grows handle. Perhaps ironic they made that change in California, where they raised rakes to grow).
We can argue numbers until we're blue in the face - maybe these aren't "CHRIMS" numbers, or maybe there was bad weather in January, or maybe the return of the NHL played a part. But down to its simplest terms: Los Al raised rakes in 2010 to grow the horse population, stay racing four days a week, and as a corollary, hike handle with better field size and a better product. That was their mission with the takeout hike and it's why it passed the CHRB.
Three years later, that has failed to occur.
They are racing three days a week, not four, and handle per week has fallen by a good amount. On track handle, which the track and purses get the most money from, is down precipitously. I believe this should act as a cautionary message to any track or horsemen group who believes they can raise prices on their customer base and prosper.
Thursday, February 21, 2013
Wednesday, February 20, 2013
Small Ball
There was a lot of chatter about Paulick's article which talked about corporate responsibility and some recent racing decisions yesterday. Even (it appears) former NYRA CEO Charles Hayward got into the discussion, which spurred even more chatter.
In the article, Baconater used Maker's Mark bourbon as an example, and it is a good one, in my opinion. Maker's Mark was having supply issues so they played small ball - they talked about changing the alcohol content of their product with the hopes of keeping sales just as they were. It was a seeming 'tinker', but that tinker snowballed. They backed off.
What happens in horse racing is similar. The 'tinkers' affect the brand, and turn into a real issue. If a faucet keeps dripping it can turn into a gush.
The problem I have with small ball in horse racing, is that not only do the tinkers rarely help change the industry, they deflect from the industry looking at their real issues.
New York is perhaps the best example of pure small ball. Let's raise takeout, which never works, to pay for OTB's that weren't working. This sounds like a George Costanza initiative at Vandelay Industries. If this policy didn't blow up it would've been shocking.
California was not dissimilar. The goal of increasing a purse, say from $30,000 to $32,000 is deemed the holy grail; like it somehow is going to shake the foundations of owner behavior and the sport itself. It was deemed worthy of annoying fans, and bettors when they passed the rake hike.
What really does a $2,000, or $4,000 bump in a purse do? Not much. For large stables it may turn their ROI up from 0.52 to 0.54. For mom and pops, the product itself, reinvestment in yearlings or people moving from other states the benefits are negligible. Is it worth hurting your brand?
NYRA had a nice bump in purses this year with slots. Is Aqueduct the holy grail? Was last year's Saratoga meet that much different than others? Did you hear anyone say "I don't want to race at Toga for a $70,000 maiden special weight, but at $75,000, count me in!"
I don't want to belittle slots in New York, because it is a major development, but as a rule, marginal increases in a purse will not set the industry free. It will help of course, but it's small ball.
Conversely there are big items that actually can help turn the industry on its head and nothing ever seems to get done.
In Canada, John Craig, a horse owner and lawyer petitioned the Supreme Court recently to allow more deductions on income for horse ownership as "farming income". He won. Perhaps sometime the $8,750 cap will be done away with, and if so, horse ownership could increase massively as an investment vehicle. This is "big ball" not small ball, yet one man, taking it upon himself did this work.
In the US, if the horseplayer tax that was implemented in the 1960's was done away with, handle might head north tomorrow by $4 or $5 billion. At 7% for purses, that's about a $350 million dollar yearly purse increase for horse racing. $350 million is about what slots in every jurisdiction in the US supplies purses with each year. This is big stuff.
Instead of the Flock of Seagulls at Hollywood Park, why didn't we invite Willie Nelson? Decreasing a tax that can help farming like the horseplayer tax reduction can with increased purses could've been part of it, no? More purses equals more feed, and help, and bedding. and paddocks, and barns, and pasture lands. It's what the whole Farm Aid thing was about.
Where was the industry the past 25 years on these huge items that can change the sport in a positive fashion forever for us as horse owners and horseplayers? It's seems they were focused on small ball, and small ball rarely changes a thing. In some cases it does more harm than good.
In the article, Baconater used Maker's Mark bourbon as an example, and it is a good one, in my opinion. Maker's Mark was having supply issues so they played small ball - they talked about changing the alcohol content of their product with the hopes of keeping sales just as they were. It was a seeming 'tinker', but that tinker snowballed. They backed off.
What happens in horse racing is similar. The 'tinkers' affect the brand, and turn into a real issue. If a faucet keeps dripping it can turn into a gush.
The problem I have with small ball in horse racing, is that not only do the tinkers rarely help change the industry, they deflect from the industry looking at their real issues.
New York is perhaps the best example of pure small ball. Let's raise takeout, which never works, to pay for OTB's that weren't working. This sounds like a George Costanza initiative at Vandelay Industries. If this policy didn't blow up it would've been shocking.
California was not dissimilar. The goal of increasing a purse, say from $30,000 to $32,000 is deemed the holy grail; like it somehow is going to shake the foundations of owner behavior and the sport itself. It was deemed worthy of annoying fans, and bettors when they passed the rake hike.
What really does a $2,000, or $4,000 bump in a purse do? Not much. For large stables it may turn their ROI up from 0.52 to 0.54. For mom and pops, the product itself, reinvestment in yearlings or people moving from other states the benefits are negligible. Is it worth hurting your brand?
NYRA had a nice bump in purses this year with slots. Is Aqueduct the holy grail? Was last year's Saratoga meet that much different than others? Did you hear anyone say "I don't want to race at Toga for a $70,000 maiden special weight, but at $75,000, count me in!"
I don't want to belittle slots in New York, because it is a major development, but as a rule, marginal increases in a purse will not set the industry free. It will help of course, but it's small ball.
Conversely there are big items that actually can help turn the industry on its head and nothing ever seems to get done.
In Canada, John Craig, a horse owner and lawyer petitioned the Supreme Court recently to allow more deductions on income for horse ownership as "farming income". He won. Perhaps sometime the $8,750 cap will be done away with, and if so, horse ownership could increase massively as an investment vehicle. This is "big ball" not small ball, yet one man, taking it upon himself did this work.
In the US, if the horseplayer tax that was implemented in the 1960's was done away with, handle might head north tomorrow by $4 or $5 billion. At 7% for purses, that's about a $350 million dollar yearly purse increase for horse racing. $350 million is about what slots in every jurisdiction in the US supplies purses with each year. This is big stuff.
Instead of the Flock of Seagulls at Hollywood Park, why didn't we invite Willie Nelson? Decreasing a tax that can help farming like the horseplayer tax reduction can with increased purses could've been part of it, no? More purses equals more feed, and help, and bedding. and paddocks, and barns, and pasture lands. It's what the whole Farm Aid thing was about.
Where was the industry the past 25 years on these huge items that can change the sport in a positive fashion forever for us as horse owners and horseplayers? It's seems they were focused on small ball, and small ball rarely changes a thing. In some cases it does more harm than good.
Tuesday, February 19, 2013
It's Not the Stray Cats Fault
Hollywood Park is cancelling their Friday night cards and the rock concert that accompanied them.
According to Holly Park Prez Jack Liebau, "We had a lot of people that seemed to come just for the concerts. We’re not in the concert business.”
This might make it more difficult to compete with the "Dodgers and the Giants" but nevertheless, it's the right thing to do. Hollywood Park is in the betting business, not the concert business.
Mountaineer Park in 1998 had $30,000 handles from their live crowd. They then decided they were in the betting business. They distributed their signals to everyone (even those "evil" rebaters) and pushed the bet with Mark and Nancy on a nightly basis in a neat time slot. Despite non-winners of a race since Bob Dole was majority leader for 5 claimer conditions and trainers named "Scooter", their handle was $1M a night.
Gulfstream Park is in the betting business. The Rainbow Six is a bet, not a stakes race, or a new band. It's a bet. What's garnered more buzz this meet, how many Pletcher horses with nice pedigree's win, the return of Animal Kingdom, or the Rainbow Six?
Balmoral Park is a race track that allows betting. A couple of Saturday's ago they gave away $98,000 in purses and had $1 million in handle. Meanwhile, other tracks with three and four times that purse level can barely break $400,000. Low rake, a few decent pools and a track who knows that its customers want to bet, not watch a band, can do some handle.
We're not competing with a baseball team. We shouldn't expect some dude who wants to dance to an 80's band after having nine beer compile his own pace figures for the night so he can come back tomorrow. This is not going to a Copperfield show and coming back half cut and dropping $400 at a roulette wheel. Handicapping is a brain game.
Horse racing is in the betting business. We just need to act more like it.
According to Holly Park Prez Jack Liebau, "We had a lot of people that seemed to come just for the concerts. We’re not in the concert business.”
This might make it more difficult to compete with the "Dodgers and the Giants" but nevertheless, it's the right thing to do. Hollywood Park is in the betting business, not the concert business.
Mountaineer Park in 1998 had $30,000 handles from their live crowd. They then decided they were in the betting business. They distributed their signals to everyone (even those "evil" rebaters) and pushed the bet with Mark and Nancy on a nightly basis in a neat time slot. Despite non-winners of a race since Bob Dole was majority leader for 5 claimer conditions and trainers named "Scooter", their handle was $1M a night.
Gulfstream Park is in the betting business. The Rainbow Six is a bet, not a stakes race, or a new band. It's a bet. What's garnered more buzz this meet, how many Pletcher horses with nice pedigree's win, the return of Animal Kingdom, or the Rainbow Six?
Balmoral Park is a race track that allows betting. A couple of Saturday's ago they gave away $98,000 in purses and had $1 million in handle. Meanwhile, other tracks with three and four times that purse level can barely break $400,000. Low rake, a few decent pools and a track who knows that its customers want to bet, not watch a band, can do some handle.
We're not competing with a baseball team. We shouldn't expect some dude who wants to dance to an 80's band after having nine beer compile his own pace figures for the night so he can come back tomorrow. This is not going to a Copperfield show and coming back half cut and dropping $400 at a roulette wheel. Handicapping is a brain game.
Horse racing is in the betting business. We just need to act more like it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months
-
Auckland Reactor is coming to the US from New Zealand and he landed in the barn of the very sharp Kelvin Harrison. I don't think many w...
-
Have you seen the RCI's recent push to change the narrative on drugs and racing? The story they tell is accurate, and has been for some...
-
Elmer Patzer walked up to a betting machine and started popping in tickets to see if he won. All of a sudden, whamo, he cashed for $6.5 mill...
-
Yesterday on twitter there was a conversation about why some people are withholding money from Keeneland this meet. A simple question, with...
-
Back in the early 1990's I got my first real job. I was a pretty much an office gofer for a mining consortium. One day a gentleman cam...
-
Horses opening with 10k to win on them, at smaller venues lately? I have not been playing too seriously the past two days, however I did che...
-
Every time I flip on twitter someone is annoyed that NBC is tape delaying some of the events for prime time television. Columnists have join...
-
Canterbury Park - the small Minnesota track that lowered takeout last year, only to raise it this season - concluded their meet recently. Th...
-
Good morning folks. On Awful Announcing, columnist Matt Zemek tore a hide off ESPN for what he thinks is the dumbing down of tennis cover...
Similar
Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return
Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...