Friday, January 11, 2008

The Bettor: Optimal Bet Size and More

I am the king of procrastination today. I work for myself. I should fire me for being lazy, but since I am so lazy right now I will wait to fire myself Monday.

I have chatted with Jeff Platt, founder of jcapper, a betting software. He is a sharp bettor, and has been working honing his craft for many, many years. His software is commercially available if anyone is interested.

Today he was chatting about optimal bet size, and how smaller pools and watered down product hurt the business. It is an area we somewhat explored by chatting with Ian Meyers of Premier Turf Club here.

Jeff posted up his thoughts and I asked if I could reproduce them here. He said "sure". It is a decent look at how players - serious players - approach the game, and why when pools get small, wagering gets smaller. It is a pillar in the building block belief that when a track loses handles it can snowball, and why rebating can make tracks handles' grow. It is a brilliant illustration as well that when players are handcuffed, the incentive is to bet less and that is something we obviously do not want.

It also stresses that our pools not being big enough can make people play other games, in many cases the stock market. I played fairly seriously at that game for years and I have some thoughts about that versus racing, and how I think their business plan (online trading) has hurt racing immensely (they did what we should have done, imo). I will do a post on that soon.

In addition, there seems to be this obsession at times in "getting people back to the track". Often times it is pure fallacy with big players. Jeff lets his thoughts be known on that.

For a background illustration on rebates and lower rake, check our post here.

Anyway, thanks to Jeff for these thoughts. It is a very enlightening and a nice way to glimpse into a serious players mind; and it teaches us things. Education is a good thing, very few people want to share it in betting.

Here it is:

I agree with you that rebates (or lower takeout) causes large bankroll players to approach the game differently and bet drastically more. And IMHO that's good for the game.

Why racing execs fail to see this is completely beyond me. If guys like Daruty and Coutow got their wish and managed to make the concept of ADWs and rebates evaporate overnight and force guys like me back to the track... one thing they fail to understand is that there is no way in the world I can bet anything close to my current handle on location at a track compared to what I now bet online. They need to face facts. Pandora's box is open. I'm not going back to the track. Force me back to the track and instead they will force me out of the game. I'm already dabbling successfully in swing trading... a game I consider to be far and away easier to beat than parimutuel betting. Take away rebates and where do they think I'll focus my attention?

I'm going to make a guess:

At 20k+ betting a night it isn't that hard to overload the pools at many of the smaller pooled tracks to the point where you are actually betting against yourself. As you you no doubt know there is an optimal or max bet size that each pool will support.

For those who may not be aware I'm going to take a stab at illustrating this.

Optimal bet size is the bet size that produces not max roi but max profits for the player. It's based on pool size, takeout, and the strength of your play. In a perfect world you could calculate it ahead of time. But in real life, because you can't know the exact ending size of the pool with your bet in it before you bet, you can only make an educated guess as to what it actually turns out to be.

I'll use the following chart to illustrate my point. Here I am simulating the performance of WIN bets at track with a win pool similar in size to that found at GGX or BM. Using a UDM or spot play that has on paper produced a 1.15 roi over a race meet with 200 hypothetical plays where takeout and the average pool size dictates each additional $100 bet lowers roi by 2 percent, here's what happens:

Bet Amt Net
Size Plays Bet ROI Profit
$10 200 $2000 1.15 $300
$50 200 $10000 1.14 $1400
$100 200 $20000 1.12 $2400
$200 200 $40000 1.10 $4000
$300 200 $60000 1.08 $4800
$350 200 $70000 1.07 $4900
$400 200 $80000 1.06 $4800
$500 200 $100000 1.04 $4000
$600 200 $120000 1.02 $2400

Notice that max roi happens with tiny bets. As the player increases the size of his bet his roi drops. I say this shouldn't bother the player one bit. Why? Because as bet size increases so does net profit - but only up to a point - the point of optimal bet size. However, when bet size is increased beyond optimal bet size then net profit starts to decrease. In this example optimal bet size happens somewhere between $300 and $400. The same UDM (note: UDM is an acronym for "user defined model", something Jcapper allows you to do) played at a different track with a larger pool (or a lower takeout) would of course offer a larger optimal bet size and more net profit across a sample of 200 plays.

Depending on the pool and the venue it may be entirely possible for the large player to take home more by betting less.

For more thoughts from Jeff, or to try a demo of his software (thoroughbred software only), please visit him at Jcapper.com.

Ledford News & Prairie Meadows Note

The New York Daily News has a Ledford story up, with a few quotes and notes.

From attorney Howard Taylor:

"Criminally, Eric is clear," said Taylor. "He's licensed and I do not believe that there is any state that would refuse him a license.

"The problem is privately-owned racetracks, such as Freehold or Pocono Downs. They can say 'We don't want you racing here.' "


And as we knew from stories like this before:

Because it is owned by the state, the Meadowlands has no choice but to let Ledford participate.

So, that part is clear. Since we have no official word from the Meadowlands that they are trying something else, I guess we can assume he'll be down there on horses soon. As for private tracks? That is yet to be determined it seems.

As for Freehold, track general manager Don Codey said: "He hasn't appeared on an overnight or come forward as of yet. When that happens, we'll have to take a look at it and see if it is in the best interests of Freehold Raceway to permit him to race here."

According to Mr. Taylor, some people within the industry seem to be ready to welcome him back with open arms:

"I know of four major stables that he has talked to," said Taylor, "and will be using him."

Andrew Cohen in his wire to wire yesterday, pointed out that he disagrees with the way punishment in meted out in racing; and if we are upset that people like this are being reinstated after being criminally charged in racing, we should blame the powers who govern the sport.

be angry at the people in positions of power who allow these lackluster punishments to be meted out; who place them in the rulebooks to begin with, and who fail to provide enough funding to make the system work properly.

I do not know why simple rules are not established and followed-through on in racing. For example, I once worked at a big bank and I had to have a background check. If that background check revealed I had been criminally convicted of something in banking before, I would not be eligible to work in the banking industry. The same goes for the securities industry. Similarly, I think if I worked at a casino in Vegas and was criminally convicted of something there, the chances are between zero and zero I would be able to reapply at a casino to make my living. These industries seem to believe integrity of their businesses are of utmost importance.

Why do we not have the same rules in racing? I think it all goes back to two things: We were a monopoly so these things didn't have to be looked at; and we have no leadership.

I think someone out there should work on getting this changed. If you are convicted of a crime having something to do with the sport, e.g. horse abuse, illegal possession of equine drugs, fixing a race contest - anything along those lines, we should do what the stock market or casinos do: Boot you out forever.

Meanwhile, the debate rages on at Prairie Meadows. As opined below, the track and state government is looking at how slot money is doled out in Iowa. It is reported that this is ongoing. They are starting to look at the cost side of the business and seeing how they can hopefully become more cost conscious and perhaps self sustainable.

Prairie Meadows said it would examine the length of the racing season and look for ways to get bigger fields and increase pari-mutuel betting.

We will keep updating the Iowa situation, as it might have far-reaching effects on our sport.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

Breaking News: Rucker/Ledford

Well breaking news in harness racing anyway, which seems to be kinda slow.

Anyhow, Andrew Cohen in this weeks wire to wire, just out, says he received correspondence from Tad Stockman, who is an exec at the Meadowlands.

Regarding Rucker:

Tad Stockman at the Big M emailed me Thursday with news of a new “Rucker Agreement.” He wrote this: To my knowledge Ken Rucker has a clean record for class 1 positives for the last 2 years and is currently licensed by the NJRC. We reached a new confidential agreement as to the policies and procedures he must adhere to for participation at The Meadowlands.”


So it appears that the Meadowlands struck a new deal.

At whose behest? Why would they not keep the old ban going? What benefit to harness racing do they see from reinstating racing privileges to him? Have they been reading fan reaction?

Questions we will keep looking for answers to when scanning the news.

If we get something, we'll post it up.

Most Trafficked, Last 12 Months

Similar

Carryovers Provide Big Reach and an Immediate Return

Sinking marketing money directly into the horseplayer by seeding pools is effective, in both theory and practice In Ontario and elsewher...